Spot The Steal - Ann Taylor Loft Flutter Silk Dress

I saw this dress at Loft the other day but couldn't believe the $128 price tag on it, so I went on the hunt for a similar looking dress and here it is for a lot less! Which one do you like better?

Flutter Silk Dress, Loft $128
Ruffled Shimmer Georgette Dress, Forever21 $27.80