Spot The Steal - Valentino Caged Rockstar Flat

It's no secret that I'm not a flats girl at the slightest.  Somehow they end up hurting my feet more than my heels ever would (I'm also 5'3, and need the height help, so there's that). But when I saw Julia raving about her new flats I couldn't help but want to jump on board, especially when they resemble Valentino's so closely. Also, they're just under $17! 

My thoughts... Why not?

Shoedazzle Nakia, $16.78 (also in red!)

Which would you pick?