Spot The Steal - Cynthia Vincent Dinah Sandal

I've been seeing these all over the place, and they're growing on me - especially in purple! Though I have a deep respect for Cynthia Vincent and her shoes, they just aren't in my price range. However, I have found a fewer cheaper 'identical' version's of Cynthia's Dinah sandal from Steve Madden, Target and now Kmart (cheapest) for under $50. Can you Spot the Steal?

Cynthia Vincent Dinah, $216
McKinsey Sandal, Kmart $12.99 - also available in Blue and Purple